GTA VI just broke Metacritic with a 99 — and one critic’s 80/100 score is sparking a huge debate

After more than a decade of memes, delays, and sky-high expectations, the reviews for Grand Theft Auto VI are finally in – and somehow, Rockstar actually pulled it off.

GTA VI has debuted at a jaw-dropping 99 on Metacritic based on over 150 critic reviews, with not a single mixed or negative score on the board. That puts it past GTA V (97) and GTA IV to become Rockstar’s highest-rated game ever, climbing straight to the top of Metacritic’s all-time chart alongside 1998’s The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time. Major outlets like IGN and GameSpot handed out 10/10s, while Bloomberg’s Jason Schreier called it a straight-up masterpiece on the same tier as Breath of the Wild and Elden Ring.

Still, in true internet fashion, fans aren’t just celebrating the 99 – they’re hyper-focused on the one outlier pulling the average down.

Right now, the lowest score on Metacritic belongs to ScreenHub, which gave GTA VI an 80/100 (4/5). Even though an 80 is still a solid “green” score, the review quickly became a hot topic across Reddit because of its surprisingly blunt complaints. According to the reviewer, GTA VI doesn’t actually start getting fun until roughly 25 hours in, drags its feet with too much unskippable filler, and bogs players down with tedious everyday chores – like making sure Jason and Lucia eat healthy food and hit the gym.

That take has already kicked off a mini debate among players and critics. While reviewers generally agree the main campaign is massive (taking around 60+ hours if you stick mostly to the story), others – including Schreier in his video review—pointed out that the hardcore life-sim mechanics like gym workouts and protein shakes are completely optional, and that Leonida’s chaotic random encounters are what keep the game gripping from the jump.

Whether you’re here for a 60-hour crime epic or just want to work out and renovate houses, one thing is clear: even GTA VI’s “harshest” review still gave it a 4 out of 5.

Add Comment